NOW IN 22 DIFFERENT LANGUAGES. CLICK ON THE LOWER LEFT HAND CORNER “TRANSLATE” TAB TO FIND YOURS!
By Jeff J. Brown
Pictured above: no wonder Chinese and Westerners don’t understand each other. They look at the world and their societies with diametrically opposed points of view. It’s like two peoples staring at each other through the opposite ends of a telescope. Everything is distorted. To paraphrase the great American poet Robert Frost, “And that my friends, makes all the difference”.
Thousands of dollars are needed every year to pay for expensive anti-hacking systems, controls and monitoring. This website has to defend itself from tens of expert hack attacks every day! It’s never ending. So, please help keep the truth from being censored and contribute to the cause.
Paypal to
je**@br***********.com
. Thank you.
Do your friends, family and colleagues a favor to make sure they are Sino-smart:
Journalism: https://chinarising.puntopress.com/blog-2/
Books: http://chinarising.puntopress.com/2017/05/19/the-china-trilogy/ and
https://chinarising.puntopress.com/2018/06/18/praise-for-the-china-trilogy-the-votes-are-in-it-r-o-c-k-s-what-are-you-waiting-for/
Website: www.chinarising.puntopress.com
Twitter: https://twitter.com/44_Days
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/44DaysPublishing
VK: https://vk.com/chinarisingradiosinoland
Mobile phone app: http://apps.monk.ee/tyrion
About me: https://chinarising.puntopress.com/about-the-author/
Live from the streets of China, Jeff
Downloadable SoundCloud podcast (also at the bottom of this page), YouTube video, as well as being syndicated on iTunes, Stitcher Radio, RUvid and Ivoox (links below),
Note before starting: if you have not already done so, reading/listening to/watching my two recent posts comparing Chinese and Western governance will make this one much more meaningful (https://chinarising.puntopress.com/2019/07/30/why-are-western-leaders-gawd-awful-bad-and-chinas-so-darn-competent-part-i-china-rising-radio-sinoland-190730/ and https://chinarising.puntopress.com/2019/08/07/why-are-western-leaders-gawd-awful-bad-and-chinas-so-darn-competent%ef%bc%9fpart-ii-china-rising-radio-sinoland-190807/).
Westerners can live and work in China for years and not see the obvious. I should know, since I was one of them. We occidentals are so brainwashed from birth, at home, in school, by government, media and advertising of our moral superiority over all those “other” dark skinned kinda-sorta people, that it’s easy to not see the trees in the proverbial forest of life. This is how I was, when living here from 1990-1997. Even after living and working for 21 years outside the US, mostly in Africa, Middle East and China, I was still blinded by my racism of Western cultural and moral superiority, a liberaloid do-gooder, wrapped up in identity politics, thinking I was better than most of my less cosmopolitan countrymen – sad to say – and I wasn’t much better. It was not until we came back to China in 2010 that the scales of racism finally fell from my eyes. This painful and humbling, but ultimately liberating experience is tracked through the three books of The China Trilogy (see below).
Looking at the above comparative chart and going back to the times of the Ancient Greeks, the quintessential Marlboro Man has been the fixture of Western civilization. Me, myself and I, free and unfettered, independent and on one’s own, to decide one’s destiny. Being an adventurer and warrior/gunslinger also fits the bill. Greek tales like Jason and the Argonauts, Iliad and the Odyssey and the swashbuckling myths of the deities slaughtering monsters (today’s inferior Dreaded Others) all extol the virtues of Solo Man.
Family comes next and even that is often contested and dysfunctional in the West. Help out a family member? Maybe, maybe not. It seems like every Western family I’ve ever gotten to know well, starting with mine, is rife with communication and contact between members cut off. Individual peeves and grudges trump trying to keep the family intact.
Working our way down this civilizational hierarchy, support for the neighborhood, city, province and country can happen, but frequently on “my terms” and “not in my backyard”. How dare you encroach on my freedoms! This, while citizens can be easily brainwashed with God and the flag, to fight in endless wars for rape, resources and plunder, with the price over the long term eventually being societal collapse.
For millennia, at the bottom of the Western shit heap is the government and leaders. You can’t blame Euranglolanders for not trusting or respecting their governments, since they usually act like gangsters stealing from the 99%, while sending the latter to die likes dogs in wars of expansion, exploitation and extraction, all to enrich their elite 1% masters. Organized criminals posing as leaders and governments masking cartels is standard operating procedure. It’s happening while I write.
Yet, in spite of all the pitfalls, it’s easy to see why the Western hierarchy of Solo Man is so intoxicating and flattering. What could be more important than… ME! One’s horizon in life is simplified. Me, myself and I concentrate the need and take complexity and nuance out of the equation. Life become linear, point A to point B. I’ll do whatever the hell I want, Bubba. Get back Jojo, it’s my space. Get outta of my way, this is MY lane! A friend in need is fucked indeed. What’s in it for me? The world is my oyster. Of course, I should be able wear a gun around town to protect myself. I’ve got individual rights. Ayn Rand’s “rational self-interest”. Gordon Gekko’s greed is not just good, greed is God. What’s mine is mine and what’s yours in mine, so you’re screwed. Might and treachery make right. Finders keepers losers weepers. Laissez-faire, bay-bee. Dog eat dog, the big dominate the little, the rich steal from the poor. Being entertained and amused becomes paramount. Mass production and super-consumption are in. More, more, more. Making personal sacrifices is decidedly uncool, as is delayed gratification. It is easy to see why the Western paradigm of Marlboro Man dovetails so perfectly with capitalism, neoliberalism and colonialism.
Now, in China, flip the West’s social hierarchy upside down. Suddenly, you are no longer Mr. and Mrs. Me. Welcome to being at the very bottom of civilization’s needs. Look up and your life is no longer simple and linear, but complex and elliptical – a tapestry of interconnections and expectations. Just in the family alone, Mom’s, Dad’s and Grandparents’ needs trump yours. Older relatives too. What’s mine is also my family’s. If you slack off, then how is the family supposed to help take care of the neighborhood? We all want to live in a nice town/city, don’t we, and you’re the start. Daily life becomes very intricate, cyclical and circular, giving and taking. This is not my lane, but everyone else’s too. Since life is so interwoven and interdependent, solidarity in helping others becomes the ideal. Suddenly, social harmony and peaceful coexistence are everything. You mean I have to share? I have many responsibilities to my community and country? You mean I should help the government and our leaders to work effectively, and keep the nation intact and prosperous? You bet your stinky tofu, you do.
It’s easy to see that being a Chinese citizen is a much bigger daily responsibility and the expectations of the many over the wants of the individual are so much greater than in Western civilization. Euranglolanders often feel superior over Chinese families, when they see young children here being loud, boisterous and spoiled rotten. They are for a few years. It’s the one time in their lives when they get to enjoy some of that Solo Man Me, Myself and I, because by the time they get first grade in school, China’s civilizational hierarchy starts to kick in and the expectations of everyone around them begin to weigh on their societal shoulders. For five or six years, they get to run wild a little bit, now it’s time to knuckle down and take their place on the bottom rung of the ladder.
Since you are on the hook for family, the country’s leaders and government, attributes like frugality and delayed gratification become the ideal. No wonder the Chinese have the highest savings rate of any large economy in the world. Even though buying personal gizmos and luxuries has never been higher, and Baba Beijing is exhorting the masses to consume more, to counteract the US’s tariff trade war, China’s savings rate is still 46% (https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/china/gross-savings-rate). This compares to Americans’ 17% (https://www.ceicdata.com/en/indicator/united-states/gross-savings-rate).
All in the family. Since everybody collectively is more important than you, is it any wonder that China is a communist-socialist civilization and always has been?
It goes without saying that the two above portrayed hierarchies are meant to be painted black and white, to show the overarching contrast. Of course, there are generous, giving Westerners who believe in social solidarity and economic justice. As well, there are Chinese who are selfish, greedy and heartless. Yes, there are family feuds and estranged relatives. That’s not the point. The point is the diametrically opposed societal expectations and ideals that are held up for inspiration and guidance. In the West, it’s all about individualism and personal freedom. In China, it’s all about Mom, Dad, the mayor, governor, prime minister and president who come first.
And that, my friends, makes all the difference. The imperial West shattered China’s civilizational hierarchy for 110 years, when it flooded the country with opium, morphine and heroin, 1839-1949, and was able to rape and plunder the people with lustful abandon. Since communist liberation in 1949, China’s social hierarchy has been restored. Look at the comparative table at the beginning of this article one more time and ask yourself, Which country is going to succeed and prosper on the world stage, into the 22nd century?
I’ll give you three guesses and the first two don’t count.
Why and How China works: With a Mirror to Our Own History
JEFF J. BROWN, Editor, China Rising, and Senior Editor & China Correspondent, Dispatch from Beijing, The Greanville Post
Jeff J. Brown is a geopolitical analyst, journalist, lecturer and the author of The China Trilogy. It consists of 44 Days Backpacking in China – The Middle Kingdom in the 21st Century, with the United States, Europe and the Fate of the World in Its Looking Glass (2013); Punto Press released China Rising – Capitalist Roads, Socialist Destinations (2016); and for Badak Merah, Jeff authored China Is Communist, Dammit! – Dawn of the Red Dynasty (2017). As well, he published a textbook, Doctor WriteRead’s Treasure Trove to Great English (2015). Jeff is a Senior Editor & China Correspondent for The Greanville Post, where he keeps a column, Dispatch from Beijing and is a Global Opinion Leader at 21st Century. He also writes a column for The Saker, called the Moscow-Beijing Express. Jeff writes, interviews and podcasts on his own program, China Rising Radio Sinoland, which is also available on YouTube, Stitcher Radio, iTunes, Ivoox and RUvid. Guests have included Ramsey Clark, James Bradley, Moti Nissani, Godfree Roberts, Hiroyuki Hamada, The Saker and many others. [/su_spoiler]
Jeff can be reached at China Rising,
je**@br***********.com
, Facebook, Twitter, Wechat (Jeff_Brown-44_Days) and Whatsapp: +86-13823544196.
Read it in your language • Lealo en su idioma • Lisez-le dans votre langue • Lies es in deniner Sprache • Прочитайте это на вашем языке • 用你的语言阅读
[google-translator]
Wechat group: search the phone number +8613823544196 or my ID, Jeff_Brown-44_Days, friend request and ask Jeff to join the China Rising Radio Sinoland Wechat group. He will add you as a member, so you can join in the ongoing discussion.
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: RSS
I contribute to 
You wrote exactly what I was thinking for a while.
I am convinced both anarchist and libertarian attitudes that “the state is bad” qualify as demagogy, since they don’t take into account how complex civilisation has gotten since the discovery of agriculture. You NEED some type of large-scale organisation with diverse, specialised roles geared towards keeping members of society safe and satisfying their needs. Does the fact that knives can be used to hurt people negate their positive uses? No. In the context of US politics alone, interests like the Israel lobby or agribusiness will happily use the state for their own purposes, so why not you (when the possibility arises)?
There’s the fact that most converts to right-libertarianism or the anarchist left seem to be educated Westerners in middle-income jobs or higher, who congregate with friendly like-minded people, and have never personally experienced the political instability in countries like Somalia. But look at how ordinary people keep most cities around the world in poor shape, with graffiti, rubbish and animal feces a common sight, and that’s WITH authority figures begging us to do the right thing and punishing us for crimes. And you need massive coordination just to conserve and hopefully restore the environment, or the research and engineering that made things like new forms of energy or sending crews into outer space possible. Especially in countries like my native Mexico,I think they would collapse without a state holding them together. It can’t be a coincidence that Imperial China before the Opium Wars, or the People’s Republic today, become among the most prosperous nations in history, and for long stretches of time, with a strong state? Or that Europe experienced the Renaissance (with Byzantium and Russia waiting out the Middle Ages from more comfortable positions) as city-states and central kingdoms diminished the power of local feudal elites. It makes sense to me that institutions as diverse as commerce and the rule of law will be stunted if you’re constantly at the mercy of warlords and bandits (why do you think Huawei was founded in China instead of Somalia between Siad Barre’s fall and the founding of the Union of Islamic Courts?).
Martin, bis! bravo! So well said. China has had BIG government for 5,000 years. The fact that it has been at the forefront of technology, science, industry, agriculture, commerce, and all without devouring the rest of the world is a testament to that fact.
Jeff
It goes beyond the Chinese borders. This sense of selflessness and honoring the needs of family and community above those of the individual is very prevalent in Japan as well. Through “Western eyes” this looks like servility and conformity. In practice it translates into greater social harmony, respect for others, respect for the commons and the shared destiny of those in the society. One consequence I see lacking in the West is a willingness to collectively learn from experience, both good and bad. The shared guilt about the aggressiveness of Japan which produced enormous carnage and suffering in WWII is palpable. I see a society here which wants — despite some regressive policies by the “right wing” politicos still in play — to move beyond war. Despite the propaganda from the West about alleged malign intentions by the Chinese, I think China as a whole would prefer to create a world where wars of aggression are a thing of the past.
Thanks for sharing, John! Confucism-Daoism-Buddhism has a huge influence across Asia.
How does Mao and the atrocities I’ve read about fit with the statement, ‘1949 Communist liberation?’ Have I fallen in with a biased examination of history? This of course does not invalidate the fact that China has never has an individual based priority. I’m going to take a look at your books, I found your writings very informative
Thanks, Berlin for reading. I have spent hundreds of hours researching Mao and his era. There were no atrocities. It is estimated that about 2,500,000 bad or corrupt landlords, GMT and Western agents were killed, to realize the Land to Tiller Program. That was about 0.005 of the total population. 99% of the landlords and agents were rehabilitated, including the last emperor! Mao was all about educating, not getting revenge.
For the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, I’ll have to ask you to read “China Rising” and “China Is Communist Dammit!”, the last two books of “The China Trilogy”, where you can read many revealing and informative pages on these two subjects.
Sino-best, Jeff
Got my answer.
The atrocities happened. Their interpretation and subsequent comparison is the issue here. In this article as in Western oriented angles of interpretation, the end result is justified because it helps the masses or the 1% respectively. In either historical interpretation millions suffer from the follies of intellectuals (men who value ideas over human life) There is right way to proceed though. Both have merit. Education and access to knowledge might wake up the rural and urban. Doubt it though. Mankind prefers delusions of socialist and or capitalist and or Communist utopias. Inequality and misinformation propaganda leading to wars millions needlessly suffering will continue. Depending on your viewpoint, East or West you fight on
Good points, Berlin.
Socialism has been incredibly successful for the 99% around the world and not so good for the 1%. In capitalist countries, the 1% control the media and it is in their interests to demonize and destroy all models of socialism-communism around the world.